The Hamptons’ Fashionable Flavors

Words by Casey Brennan, Fashion by Shelby Comroe

WHERE: Duryea’s Montauk

WEAR: MIU MIU

Boating to lunch? Yes, please. Duryea’s Montauk offers a quintessential Hamptons experience with its stunning waterfront location — and dock for guests arriving by sea— and relaxed atmosphere. This seafood-centric restaurant is a favorite for those looking to savor fresh, local catches, lobster rolls and clam bakes to oysters and ceviche while enjoying breathtaking views of Fort Pond Bay. The outdoor seating area, with its nautical decor and panoramic vistas, provides the perfect setting for a leisurely meal by the water. The casual, laid-back vibe, combined with impeccable service and stunning scenery, makes Duryea’s a fashionable dining destination, where guests can unwind, savor delicious food, and soak in the natural beauty of the Hamptons. 5 Tuthill Road Montauk, NY 11954; duryeas.com.

WHERE: Sartiano’s at Hedges Inn

WEAR: COPERNI

Located in a historic bed-and-breakfast, Sartiano’s at Hedges Inn is a newbie to the culinary scene out East. After becoming one of the hardest reservations in NYC, Scott Sartiano — also the founder of buzzy member-only spot Zero Bond — and Bond Hospitality has brought the concept to East Hampton. Open Thursday through Saturday for dinner service and with priority reservations going to American Express Centurion members, the restaurant offers an elegant dining experience, seamlessly blending classic charm with contemporary flair. With a menu crafted by three-time James Beard award-winning chef Alfred Portale, guests can enjoy House made Focaccia and Crispy Zucchini Flowers, Maine Lobster Bucatini, Wild Mushroom Lasagna and Local Swordfish all summer long. 74 James Lane, East Hampton, NY 11937; thehedgesinn.com/dining.

WHERE: Nick & Toni’s

WEAR: BOTTEGA VENETA

Nick & Toni’s in East Hampton is a cornerstone of the Hamptons’ dining scene, renowned for its rustic elegance and celebrity clientele. This Italian-inspired restaurant has been a favorite since opening in 1988, offering a warm and intimate dining experience that feels both upscale and homey. The decor, featuring a wood-burning oven, Tuscan tiles, and soft lighting, creates an inviting ambiance that is perfect for any occasion while the menu showcases seasonal, farm-to-table dishes with a Mediterranean flair, from handmade pastas and wood-fired pizzas to fresh seafood and locally sourced vegetables. The restaurant’s reputation for exceptional food and service, along with its frequent celebrity sightings — Sting, Brad Pitt, Billy Joel and the Spielberg’s are all fans — has cemented its status as a fashionable and iconic destination in the Hamptons, making it a must-visit for food enthusiasts and trendsetters alike. 136 N Main St, East Hampton, NY 11937; nickandtonis.com.

WHERE: Casa Sereña at The Surf Lodge

WEAR: ATTICO

Since opening in 2007, The Surf Lodge in Montauk has become synonymous with laid-back luxury, attracting a stylish crowd to its vibrant beachfront location and unforgettable musical performances. This iconic spot is not just a restaurant but a lifestyle destination, offering a unique blend of casual elegance and coastal cool. With its bohemian-chic decor, panoramic views of Fort Pond, The Surf Lodge embodies the spirit of Montauk’s surf culture. With the debut of Casa Sereña at The Surf Lodge, founder and creative director Jayma Cardoso and chef Robert Sieber, there is a reason to pay a visit. The menu features fresh, locally sourced ingredients, featuring dishes that highlight the flavors of the sea and land, including Alaskan King Crab Legs, Grilled Mediterranean Sea Bass and Skirt Steak Frites — celebrity sightings and Instagram-worthy sunsets included. 183 Edgemere St., Montauk, NY 11954; thesurflodge.com.

WHERE: TUTTO IL GIORNO

WEAR: CHANEL

With three locations in the Hamptons — and one soon coming in Palm Beach. Florida — Tutto Il Giorno in has become a premier dining destination, cherished by those in the know in The Hamptons. And no wonder the fashionable set out East are fans: it’s the brainchild of Gaby Karan De Felice, design icon Donna’s daughter. Beloved for its authentic Italian cuisine, the restaurant blends rustic charm with modern sophistication. The seasonal menu, curated with locally sourced ingredients, features dishes such as handmade pastas, fresh seafood, and sumptuous desserts, all prepared with a genuine Italian flair. The cozy yet chic ambiance, including the outdoor seating area, makes it a perfect spot for intimate dinners. 56 Nugent Street, Southampton, NY 11968; 55 Main Street, East Hampton, NY 11937; 16 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963; tuttoilgiorno.com.

Read GRAZIA USA’s Hamptons August Gazette: